Skip to content
2025 Federal Trialtrial-daytrial-dayAnna M. EstevaoCasandra VenturacrossDay 8 - May 15, 2025The court issued a Rule 412 ruling before the jury returned, then Casandra Ventura's cross-examination continued through messages, recordings, drug use, secrecy, and her accounts of alleged incidents.
← Day 72025 Federal TrialDay 9 →

Day 8 - May 15, 2025

Rule 412 Ruling and Casandra Ventura Cross-Examination

Judge Arun Subramanian
3Proceedings
3Pages
1Witnesses
3,983Lines
1Sidebars
Day 8 of 39
Appearing:

The court issued a Rule 412 ruling before the jury returned, then Casandra Ventura's cross-examination continued through messages, recordings, drug use, secrecy, and her accounts of alleged incidents.

Full day summary

Before the jury returned, the court ruled that Rule 412 applied to challenged defense text-message excerpts and excluded them, while permitting questions about other relationships and appropriate redactions. During continued cross-examination, Casandra Ventura answered questions about messages concerning relationship conflicts, freak-offs, recordings, drug use, and her communications involving Mr. Mescudi. She agreed that some messages discussed planning encounters, said she did not want sexual videos recorded, and qualified several defense characterizations of her motives, secrecy, and recollections. She maintained that she saw the alleged balcony incident involving Ms. Bongolan and clarified that she did not see the alleged hanger strike on Ms. Morgan. The court directed counsel to clarify non-hearsay purposes for messages, streamline exhibit review, and prepare for completion of cross-examination.

1. Rule 412 Ruling and Exhibit Disclosures

Before the jury returned on Day 8, the court excluded challenged text-message excerpts concerning Ms. Ventura and addressed the defense's late exhibit disclosures.

Procedural
Rule 412 Evidentiary Ruling and Exhibit Disclosures
147 lines

The court excluded challenged text-message content under Rule 412, while allowing other relationship questioning and possible redactions; it also pressed the parties to resolve defense-exhibit disclosure disputes.

← Day 72025 Federal TrialDay 9 →