Skip to content
2025 Federal Trialtrial-daytrial-dayMaurene R. ComeyMary C. SlavikXavier R. DonaldsonBrian SteelIsrael FlorezDaniel Phillipjury_instructionsopening_statementdirectcrossredirectrecrossDay 5 - May 12, 2025A jury was sworn, both sides delivered opening statements, and former hotel security official Israel Florez and Daniel Phillip testified about events involving Sean Combs and Casandra Ventura.
← Jury Selection Day 42025 Federal TrialDay 6 →

Day 5 - May 12, 2025

Jury Sworn, Openings Delivered, and Florez and Phillip Testify

Judge Arun Subramanian
12Proceedings
7Pages
2Witnesses
2,550Lines
2Sidebars
Day 5 of 39
Appearing:

A jury was sworn, both sides delivered opening statements, and former hotel security official Israel Florez and Daniel Phillip testified about events involving Sean Combs and Casandra Ventura.

Full day summary

A jury of 12 jurors and 6 alternates was sworn after the court denied a renewed Batson application. Judge Arun Subramanian gave preliminary instructions on the presumption of innocence, the government's burden of proof, and the prohibition on outside research or discussion. In opening statements, prosecutors alleged that Sean Combs used an inner circle and business resources to commit and conceal crimes involving Casandra Ventura and Jane; the defense argued that the government would not prove racketeering, sex trafficking, or interstate transportation for prostitution, while acknowledging the jury would hear evidence of domestic violence and drug use. The court conditionally admitted one InterContinental Hotel incident report subject to a business-record foundation, excluded another version containing added characterizations of video evidence, and received four stipulations. Former hotel security official Israel Florez testified about responding to a March 2016 report involving Combs and Ventura, Ventura's stated wish to leave, his account of an offer of cash, and hotel surveillance and cell-phone recordings. Daniel Phillip testified about paid sexual encounters with Ventura while Combs was present, directions he said Combs gave during encounters, and incidents in which he said he saw or heard Combs assault Ventura. On cross-examination, the defense questioned both witnesses about details and prior accounts, and the court instructed Phillip not to discuss his ongoing testimony with counsel or the government until it resumed.

6. Israel Florez — Direct/Cross/Redirect/Recross

Former hotel security official Israel Florez completed testimony about his 2016 response at the InterContinental Hotel, including questions about his incident report and surveillance footage.

Direct
Israel Florez — Direct Israel Florez Mary C. Slavik
826 lines

Hotel security official Israel Florez described responding to the 2016 sixth-floor incident, Ms. Cassie's wish to leave, a reported cash offer, and the incident report and videos admitted through him.

Cross
Israel Florez — Cross Israel Florez Brian Steel
390 lines

Defense counsel used Florez’s 2016 incident report to question details in his later testimony; Florez said some omissions were not significant or had been communicated to hotel management.

Redirect
Israel Florez — Redirect Israel Florez Mary C. Slavik
41 lines

Florez said incident reports did not include every detail and described the cash-offer statement and video footage he said showed Combs dragging Cassie toward the room.

Recross
Israel Florez — Recross Israel Florez Brian Steel
26 lines

Florez agreed that gaps in motion-sensored surveillance footage could result from no significant movement or a system problem.

← Jury Selection Day 42025 Federal TrialDay 6 →